Argument from Change (Aquinas)

Thomas Aquinas’ 1st way  to the existence of God:

1. Some things are in motion (i.e. changing). (e.g. my water going from hot to cold, going from healthy to sick)
2. A thing cannot, in the same respect and in the same way, move itself: it requires a mover.
3. A regress of movers cannot extend ad infinitum (i.e. an infinite regress doesn’t actually solve the problem)
4. Therefore, there is an unmoved mover from whom all motion proceeds.

The key premise is 3. The idea behind the third premise is that you can’t give what you don’t have (formally or imminently); there must be something that actualizes each thing’s potential. If I get a book from Joe, Joe gets the book from Amy, and Amy gets the book from Alex, then I can’t give the book to someone else if Alex doesn’t have the book. Now suppose the passing of the book goes on to infinity. That is, there’s always a person behind the other person. But remember, you can’t give what you don’t have. If there’s no first person with the book, nobody gets it EVEN IF the series goes back ad infinitum. Likewise, EVEN IF there’s an infinite number of train cars, nothing gets the ball rolling if there’s no engine. Similarly, even if a spoon stretches outwards to infinity, it doesn’t change unless there’s something to change it.

The main objection is that Aquinas’ argument here (particularly his regress premise, which also shows up in his 2nd way and 3rd way) relies on a particular formulation of the PSR which is highly controversial

#Rebuttal to Aquinas’ 1st way #Response #Summary #1st way #Change #motion #infinite series #back to infinity #infinite chain #PSR #Principle of Sufficient Reason


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s